Thursday, March 3, 2011

Sweden and Negative Interest Rates

Today Matthew Yglesias is hyping Sweden's recent rosy economic data in a post titled "Unorthodox Monetary Policy Worked Nicely In Sweden; Will Anyone Notice?"

He's referring to the fact that in 2009 there was a wave of articles claiming that Sweden's central bank, the Riksbank, would be charging a negative interest rate on reserves held as cash at the central bank in an attempt to get banks to lend more.

As I noted yesterday, this idea is hogwash - banks don't lend their reserves to the public and interest on reserves doesn't have any direct effect on banks lending behavior. Indeed, the New York Times corrected the record on Carter Dougherty's economics blog just a few weeks after the initial erroneous reports in an article called "Negative Interest Rates in Sweden?"

The truth is, Sweden never charged banks a negative interest rate on overnight deposits; that's the significant interest rate on bank reserves. They actually paid a positive interest rate on reserves, just as most central banks now do.

Sweden's monetary policy was aggressive for sure! Proponents of more aggressive central bank policy would do well to learn about what the Riksbank actually did, and how it worked. There's a document called The Lower Limit of the Riksbank's Repo Rateavailable online that allows anyone to do just that.

But no one is helped when we try to do analysis based on hype instead of facts. Press reports often get technical details wrong; it pays to follow up with people who know what they are talking about.

Wednesday, March 2, 2011

Don't Take It From Me

Warren Mosler unearths a good quote from Vitor Constancio, a Vice President at the European Central Bank:


“The level of bank reserves hardly figures in banks lending decisions; the supply of credit outstanding is determined by banks’ perceptions of risk/reward trade-offs and demand for credit”.


This is an extraordinarily important point that economists and journalists get wrong ALL THE TIME. Remember it the next time you read someone saying that we need to inject money into the banking system so that banks will make more loans to the public. It doesn't work that way. Banks ALWAYS loan when they have profitable lending opportunities at prevailing interest rates, and NEVER otherwise.

Tuesday, March 1, 2011

Oil Prices and Foreign Policy

In part because of the centrality of street protests to the public image of the prewar opposition to the Iraq invasion, war supporters found it fairly easy to caricature leftist critiques of foreign policy as "No Blood for Oil" sanctimoniousness.

Today Matthew Yglesias (who was himself a war supporter who has since reformed) puts the argument much more subtly:


The goal of much of America’s terrorgenic policies is to secure our economic interests in the face of oil price shocks, but this holds up to very little cost-benefit scrutiny.


It is an operational fact of our foreign policy that US military support for Saudi Arabia and other autocratic Middle Eastern governments is motivated at least in part by a desire to control global oil prices. It is also an operational fact that US military spending in this region contributes not just to "anti-American sentiment" but to actual identifiable attacks on US personnel stationed abroad.

It's possible the tradeoff - increased economic security, decreased physical security - is worth it, but no one seems to be able to demonstrate this, and it runs counter to our stated goal to prioritize the physical security of Americans over other foreign policy concerns.

Obama and the State of Economic Policy

One of the really wonderful things about casting a vote for Barack Obama in 2008 was the belief that he would be a more curious, a more interested, and a more studious president than had been George W. Bush.

It was not a high bar to clear. Yet to look at the wasteland of economic policy over the course of Obama's first term in office, one wonders whether anyone on the Obama team has really read or understood anything about economics in the last 20 years.

It's not as if one has to go off the beaten path to find pertinent analysis that might address the economic malaise in which we find ourselves. One of the foremost students of Japan's long stagnation in the 1990's is Paul Krugman, who also happens to be one of the most famous economists alive.

What did Krugman recommend at the beginning of the Obama presidency? A bigger stimulus, gambling that reducing unemployment would prove to be more important to the economy than fighting inflation.

Today inflation stands at record lows while unemployment remains stubbornly stuck at its highest rate in over a generation. No one today could argue that Krugman was wrong in his diagnosis, yet very few of his critics have bothered to notice that he was right.

If it were only theory on which our leaders were ill-informed, we might forgive them. After all, it is the executive's job to run the government, not pontificate about it. Yet key members of the Obama team, including the President himself, sound vague and confused on the basic operational details of the economic institutions they control.

In 1998 L. Randall Wray, a brilliant young economist at the University of Missouri, published a book called Understanding Modern Money. It is not a work of theory; it is a textbook description of the operational details of the modern currency system, backed by economic, historical, and anthropological research.

Based on the administration's policies and public utterances, it would be surprising if a single member of the Obama economic team had ever read this book. Wray had a diagnosis and prescription in 2009 as well - bigger deficits and a laserlike focus on full employment of the entire work force, with price stability protected by structural changes in the government's participation in the labor economy rather than by union-busting and threatened shutdowns of vital services.

Unfortunately Obama and the Democrats can't go back in time and follow this prescription before losing the House, their Senate supermajority, and Obama's sky-high postelection approval ratings. Those advantages are already squandered.

But forgive me if I continue naively to hope that someone in the Obama White House might pick up a book and thumb through it to see if they can get some kind of clue about how to steer this ship. We've been a long time at sea, and we could use a course correction.

Saturday, February 5, 2011

Distribution and Allocation

On the off chance that this blog attracts readers who haven't read a lot about economics before, I thought I'd try, at least once a day, to do a post about the terms I'll be using on the blog.

Two big ones that sometimes confuse people (even those pretty well versed in economics) are the concepts of Distribution vs. Allocation.

Though I don't generally recommend that people get information about economics from wikipedia (there is a huge amount of false or misleading information on wikipedia economics pages) the wikipedia entries on Distribution(economics) and Allocation of Resources do a decent job of explaining what these concepts mean.

If you want the Short version, allocation has to do with economic inputs (production), while distribution has to do with economics outputs (consumption.)

Take yourself, for example. If you are like most people, your input into the economic system primarily takes the form of your labor (if you work full time, that's about 2000 hours of labor per year). The price system directs you (though it does not force you) towards jobs that pay more.

Meanwhile, you use the pay you get from your inputs to purchase economic outputs like food, clothes and shelter - that's the distribution side.

In this way the price system ensures that the outputs you extract from the economic system are similar to your inputs. Not exactly the same, though... but that's a discussion for a future post.

Losing the Tevatron

Warren Mosler noted earlier in the week one of the recent casualties of US budget cutting - the Tevatron collider in Illinois is being shut down due to a lack of funding.

If the project is being shut down because it's not a good idea (the article notes that there's a superior collider operating in Geneva), then while it's sad for the physicists that work on the project it's actually a good thing in the long run - the government shouldn't fund projects that aren't a good idea, and those physicists should be working on something else.

If, as I suspect, the project is being shut because of a perceived need to "trim the fat" and stop spending so much money... that's foolish, counterproductive, and wrong. We'll pay for it in the form of less innovation, worse physics programs, and ultimately lower living standards.

All because of a quaint fear that the US government can run out of dollars. Sad.

Social Security and Medicare - A Question of Distribution and Allocation

Over at Matthew Yglesias' place I've gotten into a lot of really good discussions with various commentators about economics and politics. I still read and comment there, but recently I've gotten the feeling I'd like to have a smaller pond of people so that we could get into a more involved discussion. The idea is that I'll take quotes from comments and use them to create further posts, creating a moderated front-page discussion without actually having to curtail the freedom of people to post what they want on the comment threads.

I don't know whether I'll be able to attract the folks I'm after (primarily thinking of DMonteith, studentee, Stephen Eldridge, and my MMT brethren like beowulf et al, but all are welcome) or whether this will just continue to be a sandbox for me to flesh out my ideas. But I thought I'd start with an issue that comes up a lot in both progressive and conservative circles - Social Security, Medicare, and "entitlements" generally.

The problem with Social Security and Medicare is often described as one of pure finance. We are spending X number of dollars on old people; thus we need to take X number of dollars away from young people. Sounds intuitive enough, but if you're reading this blog you probably already know that at the federal level it doesn't work that way.

In actuality the problem of Social Security is almost entirely one of distribution - that is, we have decided that it's within the authority of the federal government to set some minimum level of consumption for retired people that's (mostly) independent of their past or current production. When the population is older, we'll have to spend more resources meeting this standard, but there's no reason to believe this will create a problem. Old people don't actually consume that many resources (with an exception that we'll get to in a minute) so it would take a REALLY large population of elderly people to outstrip our ability to easily produce the consumer goods we need. The current dire-looking projections don't come anywhere close to that - the economy can easily meet the needs of a very large retired population.

The problem, as always, is not primarily with this distributive question. We can answer the question "what standard of living should old people be entitled to?" create a program to pay for it, and then we can provide the goods and services through the private market. Our system is very, very good at that - that's the reason that while communism prides itself on egalitarianism, the lot of the poor and working classes in a big, rich capitalist country is generally better than what they would get living in a big, rich communist country.

There is a real problem, though - old people do consume a very large share of one type of resource. That resource is medical care. As it happens, the price system does not do a good job of allocating medical resources - shortages, runaway costs, and low (even negative) marginal utility are the norm in our medical system*.

Thus our aging population will put even more strain on this system which is already under a lot of pressure. That's not good! But it's not primarily a finance problem. The problem is that our medical system doesn't work properly, and the inefficiency this failure creates is going to increase as our population gets older. You can't fix that with tax policy - you have to fix the medical system.

* You'll notice I never use the term "health care" if I can avoid it. I don't like the term as I think the concept of "health" encompasses a lot of things that don't really have much to do with the medical system. For my purposes the medical system is the system we use to deliver doctor's services to the public. It doesn't include other types of health-related consumption and production.